A distraught Josette tries to prevent a deadly duel between rivals Barnabas and Jeremiah.
Reverend Trask, a witch-hunter, interrogates Victoria, ties her to a tree and performs a rite of exorcism.
Angelique burns the tree at which the exorcism took place, causing Trask to believe Victoria is a witch.
Nathan Forbes smuggles food to Victoria, hiding in Collinwood. Trask and Joshua search for Victoria.