Carrying Barnabas’ cane, Noah Gifford disguises himself and feigns an attack against Millicent.
Nathan pretends to rescue Millicent, who believes it was Barnabas who attacked her.
At Nathan’s urging, Joshua goes to the Old House and is devastated to witness Barnabas rising from his coffin.
Barnabas tells Joshua he is the Collinsport Strangler. In pity, Joshua shoots his son through the heart.