In 1795, the beautiful and jealous witch Angelique attempts to destroy Barnabas’ romance with his fiancé, Josette DuPres. She enslaves Collins family servant Ben Stokes to assist her evil plans. Abigail Collins and Natalie DuPres find evidence they believe proves Victoria Winters is a witch. The family moves into the newly-built Collinwood mansion and the fanatical witch-hunting Reverend Trask is summoned to exorcise the Old House. A vengeful Angelique places a vampire curse on Barnabas.
Joshua implies that Jeremiah is to marry Millicent Collins. Angelique makes servant Ben Stokes her slave.
Angelique plans to make Josette fall in love with Jeremiah. She orders Ben to steal a lock of Jeremiah’s hair.
Ben finds he cannot escape Angelique’s power. Under a spell, Josette tells Jeremiah that she is in love with him.
Angelique uses a magic potion to make Jeremiah love Josette. Natalie witnesses Josette meeting with Jeremiah.
Natalie believes a witch is preventing Josette and Barnabas’ marriage. Naomi has a terrifying vision.
The mark of the devil appears on the hands of Jeremiah and Josette. Jeremiah makes a vow to depart Collinsport.
Determined to prevent Jeremiah from leaving town, Angelique transforms Joshua into a cat.
Natalie suspects that Victoria is a witch and tries to persuade Barnabas to marry Josette as soon as possible.
Angelique casts a spell while helping Josette prepare for her wedding and Josette soon vanishes.
While searching for Josette, a mysterious stranger tells Barnabas that she has left him for Jeremiah.
Abigail Collins discovers Victoria’s charm bracelet and becomes convinced that Victoria is a witch.
On the night they intend to be married, Jeremiah and Josette realize they have betrayed their families.
A distraught Josette tries to prevent a deadly duel between rivals Barnabas and Jeremiah.
Reverend Trask, a witch-hunter, interrogates Victoria, ties her to a tree and performs a rite of exorcism.
Angelique burns the tree at which the exorcism took place, causing Trask to believe Victoria is a witch.
Nathan Forbes smuggles food to Victoria, hiding in Collinwood. Trask and Joshua search for Victoria.
Angelique decides to use Sarah to make Barnabas suffer. She steals a doll belonging to Sarah.
Sarah falls mysteriously ill. A frantic Barnabas promises to marry Angelique if she cures Sarah.
Josette fears that Jeremiah will die from his wound. Later, his ghostly figure appears to her.
When Josette goes to the grave of Jeremiah and calls to him, a hand reaches out to her from the ground.
When Angelique reveals that she is to marry Barnabas, Josette attempts to hide her shock and hurt.
Abigail accuses Angelique of trickery. At Angelique’s bidding, the ghost of Jeremiah threatens Barnabas.
Joshua disinherits Barnabas for insisting on an immediate wedding. Naomi gives the Old House to Barnabas.
The ghost of Jeremiah abducts Angelique and begins to bury her in a grave. Barnabas hides Victoria.
Angelique and Barnabas are married. Later, Angelique is again threatened by the ghost of Jeremiah.
Angelique orders Ben to steal a ribbon that belongs to Abigail to enable Angelique to cast a spell.
Abigail insists that Reverend Trask must be summoned again to find and destroy the witch.
Angelique causes a fire to draw Victoria out of hiding as Trask performs another rite of exorcism.
Barnabas suspects that Angelique caused the fire. Ben reveals the identity of the witch to Barnabas.
Barnabas unsuccessfully tries to poison Angelique, but remains determined to end her villainy.
Angry and frightened by Angelique, Barnabas attempts to meet Josette. Angelique sends a bat to spy on him.
Peter Bradford agrees to represent Victoria at her trial. Barnabas pleads with Josette to leave town.
Barnabas shoots Angelique, who puts a curse on him. Moments later, a bat appears and attacks Barnabas.
Angelique desperately tries to keep Barnabas alive in order to avoid the curse she placed on him.
Josette searches for Barnabas, who has become delirious and is unable to recognize her.
Josette finds the Collins family history book from 1967 and is horrified to read of her own suicide.
Before he dies, Barnabas promises Josette he will return for her. Later, a bat flies out of the Old House.
Angelique plans to drive a wooden stake through Barnabas’ heart to prevent him from returning as a vampire.
Barnabas strangles Angelique. He discovers that he needs the blood of others to survive.
Peter secretly allows Victoria to temporarily leave her jail cell and Natalie discovers her at Collinwood.